Jump to content

Holiday World 2011


Recommended Posts

Guest Millennium

A steel coaster would completely ruin the feel of the park, not to mention HW doesn't have enough $$ to get a nice B&M coaster.

I would LOVE a GCI similar to Thunderhead. But by the field next to PP would be bad. After being to HW so many times, everytime I fall in love with their terrain coasters a bit more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

HW will probably never get a GCII. They are very close to Gravity Group (and back in the day- CCI). Like others have said, I always wanted HW to get a major steel coaster, but once I finally went to HW again I realized I'd rather have another woodie there. I do prefer wood over steel, and I think HW should stick to wood, but if they did get a steel I would NOT complain!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Millennium

Just because they have stuck with GG in the past and CCI does not mean they will not be working with GCI ever, but I do think they have worked with GG because GCI has outrageous prices.

I mean, Prowler cost 8M, which is less than 100 feet tall, and GG charged about the same for Voyage, which is much longer and taller.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just because they have stuck with GG in the past and CCI does not mean they will not be working with GCI in the future.

True, but chances are HW won't do that. It's like if your best friend owned Meijer and you always bought your stuff from there, than you decided to buy something from Walmart which is the competition store.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A steel coaster would completely ruin the feel of the park, not to mention HW doesn't have enough $$ to get a nice B&M coaster.

Voyage = $8.5 million + the cost of the new trains.

SheiKra = $13.5 million

Some B&Ms are not that expensive. A Dive Machine that doesn't top 200 feet would theoretically be even less expensive than SheiKra, and every park on Earth should have a Dive Machine if you ask me. ;) It could fit very nicely into the park!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A steel coaster would completely ruin the feel of the park, not to mention HW doesn't have enough $ to get a nice B&M coaster....

I beg to differ. Holiday World could easily afford a B & M, but I seriously doubt that would be the most effective investment in the park. The Kochs are very wise people. They will do what is best for the park...of that I have no doubt.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Remember, that it is not always about getting the coolest new ride. If there is no ROI there, then it doesn`t make much business sense to get that cool new ride.

A very simplified example follows. Why spend $10,000 buying a new arcade game that generates only $100 in revenue, when you could buy a game for $1,000 that generates $300 in revenue. Now, clearly by example is grossly oversimplified, but it illustrates the point of deciding on the best capital investment that produces the best ROI.

And on the subject of GCI and GG. Its kind of hard to compare the two, as they offer somewhat different wooden coasters. Great Coasters is like the B&M of wooden coasters. They are arguably the top of the line in terms of designs, comfort and from what I`ve heard, maintenance. On the other hand, Gravity Group rides are usually cheaper, and thus more parks can afford them. Because they are generally cheaper, maintenance may tend to be more on an ongoing basis. Each company has its own perks. I absolutely LOVE the Voyage, and I also adore Thunderhead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Whatever happens, I would hope that the new ride will be put in the field next to the Pilgrim's Plunge. Nothing worse than having a collection of old, traditional rides with a brand new, modern thrill ride towering over them. Holiday World has one of the nicest collections of traditional flat rides I know of. No steel coasters either. Holiday World is a traditional park, B&Ms don't fit the bill.

I don't think the new ride will be a coaster. I just don't see it happening. The Voyage still has national attention and attracts people on road trips to visit the park. Adding a new coaster would really seem redundant. Management seems determined to expand the water park and build new water rides, since that is the park's main draw. With that being said, they've given us two new water rides for the past two years.

I don't know if they'll keep with that or if they'll build something different. A new flat ride would fit nicely in the Thanksgiving section.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest rcfreak339

I would also love a S&S Screamin Swing...I think it would fit in well and they are just so very fun and thrilling.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Am I the only one that thinks HW is growing a bit too fast?

Since 2006, they have added significant additions each year, and another hopefully coming in 2011. I really enjoy Holiday World, but I hope it doesn't lose the family atmosphere with too many large additions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I mean, Prowler cost 8M, which is less than 100 feet tall, and GG charged about the same for Voyage, which is much longer and taller.

I'm not sure if you've ridden Prowler yet, but the ride is excellent IMO. Prowler filled a huge hole in their coaster lineup and is an absolute joy to ride to boot. It's also much more tolerable for the GP than Voyage and is thus much more re-rideable. Worlds of Fun hit a home run with that coaster and I'd say they got their money's worth.

On a quick tangent, I'm hoping that the success that Renegade and Prowler have enjoyed leads Cedar Fair to really take a hard look at adding GCIs through more of their parks. I realize that Valleyfair and Worlds of Fun don't get the traffic that bigger parks in the chain like Cedar Point or KI get, but the GP would eat up a good GCI coaster.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I mean, Prowler cost 8M, which is less than 100 feet tall, and GG charged about the same for Voyage, which is much longer and taller.

I'm not sure if you've ridden Prowler yet, but the ride is excellent IMO. Prowler filled a huge hole in their coaster lineup and is an absolute joy to ride to boot. It's also much more tolerable for the GP than Voyage and is thus much more re-rideable. Worlds of Fun hit a home run with that coaster and I'd say they got their money's worth.

On a quick tangent, I'm hoping that the success that Renegade and Prowler have enjoyed leads Cedar Fair to really take a hard look at adding GCIs through more of their parks. I realize that Valleyfair and Worlds of Fun don't get the traffic that bigger parks in the chain like Cedar Point or KI get, but the GP would eat up a good GCI coaster.

There's also the obvious difference between GCI's Prowler and HW's Voyage... Prowler is a true, 100% wooden coaster. Voyage is not... it's a steel structure... and that allowed them to go higher and farther... physically and monetarily.

Shaggy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steel structures are more of a maintenance thing. It's up to what the park chooses if they want a steel structure or a wooden one. It also depends on how the ride interacts with the enviroment.

I have to disagree. Although things like maintenance and enviroment may play a part, ultimately a steel structure coaster is much more budget concious. I guarantee that the lowered cost of installing a steel structure was why Will chose it for Voyage. He wanted more bang for his buck.

Overall, from what I have witnessed, steel structures become much rougher much sooner. Because the steel structure has much less give, then the track must take on more of the flexibility. That causes more wear and tear on the coaster running boards, and causes roughness.

I have ridden many, many steel-structured woodies that suffer from this same roughness. Voyage, IMO, is a wild and very intense coaster. It's not re-rider friendly (again my opinion) due to the intensity of the design, and inflexibility of the structure.

Shaggy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with that. Your still getting the same amount of maintenace with a wooden structure in my opinion. The structure won't give as much but the trains will and it will tear up the track like most PTC's do. It's mostly up to the park and what The Gravity Group recommends. Which you probably knew lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with that. Your still getting the same amount of maintenace with a wooden structure in my opinion. The structure won't give as much but the trains will and it will tear up the track like most PTC's do. It's mostly up to the park and what The Gravity Group recommends. Which you probably knew lol

A great example of a steel structure comperable to Voyage was Villain.

Villain was installed as part of a giant rides package when Six Flags branded Geauga Lake as Six Flags Ohio. It was built with a steel structure in order to allow the park to install a very large wooden coaster while keeping cost lower (to spend on other upgrades to the park.) The first year, Villian was an incredible ride. By year two, not so good. After that, it became virtually painful to ride.

Obviously this was partly due to the horrid Gerstlaur trains. But even so, the coaster became terribly jarring and unenjoyable very, very quickly. Most significantly, the "flying carpet" trick track section during the 1st half of the ride was literally like riding over gravel. That's because it was on a steel structure very close to the ground/footings. The steel didn't flex, the track had no where to go... so that inertia had to be absorbed elsewhere... thus the train shuddered riders throughout the whole section. It was like going over those warning divots on the side of the interstate.... you know the ones that vibrate your car when you drift too far to the shoulder? But worse...

To see for yourself... watch this video. Pay attention at the :18 to :23 portion.

Shaggy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...