The Beast and Thunderhead...two of my favorite wooden coasters. Disclaimer...I grew up on The Beast. I took my first spin in 1985 as a 10 year old, and become a coaster nut. So many great memories of riding The Beast with family and friends, in the day, night, rain, and even fog. I rode Thunderhead last summer, and again last month.
These coasters are so very different. Here are some categories I use to compare wooden coasters:
1. "In the woods" feeling
The Beast, obviously, has this in spades. Though much of it is in "clearings", you are almost always deep in the forest.
Thunderhead is set against a beautiful hill of trees, but you don't really go "in" the woods.
2. Out of control feeling
The Beast is like driving 100 mph on the interstate. Thunderhead is like driving 50mph down Lombard Street. Both are fun, but I gotta admit that I prefer the latter. Besides the lift hill and station flyby, Thunderhead does not travel 12 inches without changing direction up, down, left, or right.
Much of The Beast's track is quite linear, and the curves have large radii. This is the biggest difference between these two coasters, in my opinion.
3. Mystery
From the public walkways, one can see pretty much every part of Thunderhead. So there are no big surprises along its course.
On the other hand, every part of The Beast (except for the first lift-hill) is hidden from view. Even views from the Eiffel Tower, Diamondback and Vortex only offer glimpses of the second hill. Of course, now one can check out Google Earth or YouTube to learn what really happens out in those woods, but when I was a kid, you went into the ride blind. Added fear factor.
4. Trains
All of my rides on Thunderhead were quite comfy.
Over the years, my rides on The Beast have ranged from comfy to washboard road terrible.
5. Tunnels
I really enjoy coaster tunnels. The abrupt differences in sound and light, plus the "head-chopping" effect, never get old for me. The Beast has 4, while Thunderhead has one: the station flyby. It feels a bit different since it is so open compared to the tunnels on Beast.
6. Airtime
On my rides, nearly every hill on Thunderhead offered airtime.
I'm not sure I've ever had any on The Beast.
7. The "voyage" feeling
I used lowercase "v" because I don't mean the coaster in Santa Claus (though that coaster excels in this category) but rather the way a coaster layout takes me on a literal far away trip. These coasters have it: The Racer, Magnum, Millennium Force, Voyage, and The Beast.
These, not so much: Vortex, Mantis, Firehawk, and Thunderhead. This "voyage" aspect is not a requirement, just a nice bonus for me.
8. Emotional pacing, adrenaline
For me, Thunderhead stays between 10 and 11 (on the Spinal Tap meter) until the brake run.
The Beast is all over the place, dipping to 5 on the straight sections, and somehow reaching 12 at the entrance of the double helix.
What can I say, I love'em both.
So there you have it. Much more than my two cents. If I had to move to a deserted island and take one of these with me, it would be...Thunderhead. But The Beast, especially running at top form, would be a fine second choice.
I'm glad that I live close to both of these great coasters. They show how different and great wooden coasters can be.