I have for some reason always loved Death Row the maze portion just does it for me.
I say do
Death Row
Urgent Scare
Trail of Terror
The only one I say avoid would be
Cemetery Drive (and this is only if it has a big line)
I hear screams at the entrance to CTC from their direction throughout the night.
The main thing with Haunt that bothers me is... it is all in good fun. If you there trying to be Mr. or Mrs. Toughperson it will most likely hinder your experience. Try everything out, and always keep an open mind.
Also as far as Cut Throat, goes I'm going to speak out a bit. Yes the masks leave a bit to be desired. Also, sometimes pirates may not be scary. However, come through with the intentions to be scared, and you should at least jump. I know for a fact that our first scare gets almost every group, i hear the screams after they enter. Also, the lighting has been dimmed a bit. The park is really trying to get this one right. They have added or changed something almost every day we've been opened. As far as the scenes go they mainly try to be entertaining.
With that being said, the attraction has had some of the longest waits for a haunt attraction with it being "new". Waiting two hours may lead to a dissapointment. However, if the line isn't terrible long I recommend it for a try.